Looking to Buy in Ohio
Find agencies with characteristics associated with buying other agencies or books of business.
Agency Match uses public information and a proprietary scoring model to identify possible business opportunities. Ratings indicate potential, not confirmed interest, unless explicitly noted.
High 8 · Medium 15 · Low 90 · Insufficient Evidence 444 · Not assessed (exclusive carrier) 75 · Held: research incomplete 2
23 agencies rated High or Medium
Dustin Burgess Insurance Group LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Alliance & Akron & Wadsworth · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
A-Z Insurance Agency
Home, Auto, Life, Long-Term Care, Umbrella, Farm, HOA, Non-Profit, Business, Employee Benefits
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: High
Insurance Systems Group INC
Independent agency
Offices: Cleveland & Warren · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Beardsley Agency
Insurance, Risk Management and Financial Services
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Littman-thomas Agency INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Greenville & Bradford & Troy · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Sargent & Associates Agency (2005)
Renters insurance
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Meyer-badenhop Ins Agcy INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Leipsic · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Badenhop Agency in Hamler, Ohio
Auto, Homeowner's, Umbrella, Farm, Health, Life, Business, Event, Bonds
Looking to Buy: High
Whitaker-myers Ins Agcy INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Wooster & Ashland · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Badger Insurance Agency (1984)
Insurance, Wealth Management, Benefits, Tax
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Bickle Ins Services LLC
Independent agency
Athens · Ohio · Licensed in state
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired agencies with policies from 1909
Personal, Business, Employee Benefits, Financial Planning
Looking to Buy: High
Dwyer Family Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Cincinnati · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Herb Bell Insurance Agency
Home, Auto, Life, Business, Pet, Umbrella Insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: High · Looking to Buy: High
The Merhar Agency LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Willoughby · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Noda Agency merged with Merhar Agency in 2018
Auto, Home, Commercial, Life, Flood, Boat/Watercraft, Condo, Motorcycle, Recreational, Renters, RV, Umbrella
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Holloway Ins INC
Independent agency
Offices: Columbiana & Lisbon · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired first agency in 1977
Personal home, auto, umbrella, business, life, health, farm/agri insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Hosket Ulen Insurance Solutions LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Columbus & Dayton & Upper Arlington & Dublin & Miamisburg · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Masters & Associates Insurance
Personal, Business, Employee Benefits
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Deangelis Insurance INC
Independent agency
Offices: Stow · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired The Insurance Shop in 2009
Personal Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Recreational Vehicle Insurance, Umbrella Insurance, Business Owners Insurance, Property Insurance, Liability Insurance, Business Auto Insurance, Bonds, Life Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium
Derrow Insurance INC
Independent agency
Offices: Wellston · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Purchased Waugh Insurance
Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Devaul-buntain Insurance Agency INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Kent & Richfield · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
We have exciting news in that we have acquired another location in Richfield, Ohio – it is the Broadview Insurance Agency and is located at 4025 Broadview Rd.,
Auto, Home, Business, Life, Long-Term Care, Surety Bonds, Medicare
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
M J Knapp Insurance Agency Incorporated
Independent agency
Offices: Richwood · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Purchased Roger Shearer’s Insurance Agency
Commercial, Personal, Life, Farm, Recreational, Classic Vehicle
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Martin - Lark Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Rossford · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Insurance Solutions acquired
Personal, Business, Health, Life, Medicare Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Looking to Buy: Medium
Tuscarawas Agency Company
Independent agency
Offices: New Philadelphia & Strasburg & Barnesville & Sugarcreek · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Kemp Insurance of Barnesville provided services to clients for nearly 50 years before merging with Tuscarawas Insurance Agency in February.
Looking to Buy: Medium
The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Shelby & Mansfield · Ohio
States it grew by acquiring agencies
Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency
Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium
Campbell Insurance Group LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Carroll · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired Garner Insurance Agents
Auto, Home, Commercial, Life, Boat, RV, etc.
Business Partnerships: Medium · Looking to Buy: Medium
Dan Snyder Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Mentor · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Thomas Pyle Insurance Agency joined team
Auto, Home, Renters, Condo, Mobile Home, Life, Business, Motorcycle, RVs, etc.
Looking to Buy: Medium
Ohio Insurance & Financial Services LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Findlay · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Hollanshead-Kinsey Insurance (2023)
Personal Auto, Home, Health, Medicare, Life, RV, Personal Umbrella, Flood, Annuities, Business, Commercial, Farm, Surety Bonds, Group Health, Cyber Protection, Professional Liability
Business Partnerships: Medium · Looking to Buy: Medium
Stoermer Insurance Brokers INC
Independent agency
Offices: Dayton · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Carnegie Insurance
Commercial Lines, Personal Lines, Liquor & Special Events, Professional Liability, Environmental
Looking to Buy: Medium
Terry R Garner Agency LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Lancaster · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Email Eric Eric Womeldorf, Sales Representative Eric Womeldorf joined the Garner Insurance team in September 2017 when Terry and Teresa purchased an existing ag
Annuities, Medicare, LTC, Workplace Benefits, Tax Minimization, Life Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium
Lake Shore Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Canton & Cleveland & Green & Chardon & Boston Heights & Strongsville & Amherst & Mentor & Northfield Center & Newton Falls & Medina & Tallmadge & Ravenna · Ohio
Documented expansion (new office or book)
While the first office was located in Euclid, Mayfield became the new permanent home for the agency and has continued to expand to offices throughout Ohio in Ch
Auto, Home, Business, Life Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium
Research leads rated Low (90)
Each lead keeps the evidence already on its profile. A Low rating is not a sign the owner wants to sell.
Bowers Insurance Services Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: New Albany & Hilliard · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
6525 W. Campus Oval, STE 150, New Albany, OH 43054
Habitational Insurance, Condo Building Insurance, Homeowners Association Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Chris Arnott Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: East Liverpool & Lisbon & Toronto · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
16519 St Clair Ave East Liverpool, OH 43920
Personal and business insurance solutions
Business Partnerships: Medium
Citadel Insurance Associates LLC
Independent agency
Offices: West Chester & Blanchester · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
West Chester, OH
Personal Insurance: Auto, Home, Renters, Umbrella, Valuable Possessions
Business Partnerships: Medium
Duffy Insurance Partners LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Cincinnati · Ohio
Documented expansion (new office or book)
Shortly after, the only remaining owner of Agents Brokerage Insurance, William D Carr, relocated with Duffy Agency.
Personal and Commercial Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Eatmon Insurance Group, LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Hamilton & Columbus · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
3991 Hamilton Middletown Rd Hamilton, Ohio 45011
business, life, and auto insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Homan's Insurance LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Chickasaw & Versailles · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
98 W Franklin Street Chickasaw, OH 45826
Home, Health, Life, Vehicle, Farm, Commercial, Umbrella Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Kesner Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Lima & Delphos · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
Lima, OH
Personal Insurance, Business Insurance, Insurance by Industry
Business Partnerships: High
Mang Family Insurance, LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Youngstown & Canfield · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
1570 S Canfield-Niles Rd Suite B101 Youngstown, OH 44515
Home, Auto, Business, Life, Umbrella, Specialty Coverage
Business Partnerships: High
Navigate Risk Advisors LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Westlake & Cleveland · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
Westlake, OH - 28899 Center Ridge Road, Suite 303
Personal, Business, Employee Benefits, Medicare, Franchise
Business Partnerships: High
Reed & Baur Insurance Agency LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Athens & Logan & Pomeroy · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
2097 E State St Ste A Athens, OH 45701
Business Insurance, Farm/Home Insurance, Auto Insurance, Life Insurance
Business Partnerships: High
Sanderson Insurance INC
Independent agency
Offices: Dayton & Cincinnati & Fairborn · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
Dayton, OH
Personal, Business, Industry Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Slyman Insurance Group, INC.
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Columbus & Wilmington · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
Columbus, OH - 4701 Olentangy River Rd. Suite 102
Home, Auto, Business, Life, Health, Long Term Care, Personal Property Insurance
Business Partnerships: High
The W E Davis Insurance Agency, INC.
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Columbus & Clintonville & Reynoldsburg · Ohio
Documented expansion (new office or book)
The agency moved to the Grand Theater Building on State Street, across from Capitol Square.
Home, Auto, Life, Health, Commercial, Umbrella, Boat, RV
W C Felton Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Tiffin & Bellevue & Findlay & Fostoria & Fremont & Marion & Oak Harbor & Ottawa & Sandusky & Upper Sandusky · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
51 S. Washington St. Tiffin, Ohio 44883
Personal, Business, Financial Services, Employee Benefits, Senior Products
Business Partnerships: High
Andrew Yanok Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: St. Clairsville & Clairsville · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
256 West Main Street, St. Clairsville, OH 43950
Founding: 1972
Business Partnerships: High
Blackstone Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Bellville & Lexington · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
5888 State Route 13 Bellville, Ohio 44813
Auto, Business, Farm, Home, Life, Motorcycle & Recreation Vehicle
Business Partnerships: Medium
Brokernet INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Dublin & Akron & Dayton & Lorain · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
Dublin, OH 43017
Health, Medicare, Life & Ancillary Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Burrey Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Powell & Pickerington & St. Clairsville · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
9787 Fairway Drive Powell , Ohio 43065
Auto, Home, Life, Business, Health, Disability, Commercial Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Dry Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Chardon & Cuyahoga Falls & Chagrin Falls & Willoughby · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
320 Center St, Ste A Chardon, OH 44024
auto, home, business, contractor, bonds, life and health insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Fulmer Insurance Agency, LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Zanesville & Rushville · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
733 McIntire Ave. Zanesville, OH 43701
Business Insurance, Farm Insurance, Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Life Insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Gesler Insurance Agency INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Strongsville & New Franklin · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
10750 Pearl Road, Unit E8, Strongsville, OH 44136
Auto, Home, Renters & Condo, Personal Umbrella, Business, Life, Health, Medicare
Business Partnerships: Medium
Great Lakes Benefits INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Sandusky & Elyria · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
1325 Hull Road Sandusky, OH 44870
Retirement and Financial Planning, IRA & 401K Rollover, Income Planning, Tax Planning, CPA Prepared Tax Returns, Asset Protection, Estate Planning, Life Insurance, Long Term Care Planning
Hamilton Insurance Group INC
Independent agency
Offices: Mansfield & Gahanna · Ohio
Two or more documented offices
1669 Lexington Ave, Mansfield, OH
Auto, Home, Life, Business, Employee Benefits, Medicare Supplement
Business Partnerships: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Hartlen Insurance LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Clyde · Ohio
Documented expansion (new office or book)
The agency moved to offices on Kilbourne Street in Bellevue in 1992.
Personal/Commercial, Crop Insurance