The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency INC
Based on public information · Profile not yet claimedIndependent agency
Offices: Shelby & Mansfield · OhioThe Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency INC is an independent insurance agency licensed in Shelby, OH. Its website lists offices in Shelby, Mansfield. Lines listed: Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance. Founding or history: For over 100 years. Agency Match assessments based on public information: Looking to Buy medium; Mentorship & Peer Connections low; Business Partnerships low. 34 publicly sourced facts with links.
How we determined the info on this profile
- License record: taken from the state license roster.
- Offices: based on offices listed on the agency's website. More than one office can count toward the Looking to Buy score.
- Lines of business: based on text on the agency's website. They can count toward the Strategic Partnership score.
- Leadership: based on text on the agency's website. It can count toward the Mentorship & Peer Connection score.
- Carrier partnerships: based on carriers named on the agency's website.
- Looking to Buy: scored from documented acquisitions, growth and offices on the public record.
- Open to Selling: not enough public facts for a score.
- Mentorship & Peer Connections: scored from public signs of leadership, teaching and association ties.
- Business Partnerships: scored from specialties, markets and carriers published on the agency's website.
Research
Detailed profile
Geography
2 documented offices
Ownership events
3
Ownership
Not confirmed
Agency Match assessments
Agency Match uses public information and a proprietary scoring model to identify possible business opportunities. Ratings indicate potential, not confirmed interest, unless explicitly noted.
Looking to Buy
Medium · 45Public signs the agency buys or absorbs other agencies: past acquisitions, growth by acquisition, added offices and the depth to integrate a book.
Agency Match score: 45/100 · Medium confidence: 3+ public facts
Why: States it grew by acquiring agencies; two or more documented offices; three or more named leaders
- States it grew by acquiring agencies · Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agencyshelbyagency.com
- Two or more documented offices · 55 West Main Street Shelby, Ohio 44875shelbyagency.com
- Three or more named leaders · Justin & Tammy Armintrout, Agency Ownersshelbyagency.com
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry · For over 100 yearsshelbyagency.com
What this rating was based on (4 factors)
Based on public information. Points come from a fixed rubric. The score is a sum of points, not a probability. Confidence is shown separately and does not change the rating.
- States it grew by acquiring agencies+15 pts
- Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agencyshelbyagency.com
- Two or more documented offices+15 pts
- 55 West Main Street Shelby, Ohio 44875shelbyagency.com
- 1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield, Ohio 44906shelbyagency.com
- Three or more named leaders (supporting)+10 pts
- Justin & Tammy Armintrout, Agency Ownersshelbyagency.com
- Tammy Armintrout Presidentshelbyagency.com
- Justin Armintrout Vice Presidentshelbyagency.com
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry (supporting)+5 pts
- For over 100 yearsshelbyagency.com
Total: 45 points → Agency Match score 45/100, rated Medium (High at 60+, Medium at 35+).
Confidence (separate from the rating): Medium confidence: 3+ public facts · 7 facts from 1 website.
Not known publicly: Whether the agency is buying now and at what size; Financing and integration capacity.
Open to Selling
Acquisition Research Fit
Insufficient EvidenceNo Acquisition Research Fit rating. Years in operation alone, or size alone, is not a rating.
- Two documented office cities. Market segment A is descriptive context. Verified · +2 ptsshelbyagency.com
Confidence: low. Separate from the rating.
Not on file: Owner tenure is not established; Years in operation are not established; No internal succession document; Confirmed sale interest is unknown.
Confirmed sale interest: Unknown
Mentorship & Peer Connections
Low · 30Public signs of industry standing and willingness to share know-how: association leadership, teaching, memberships, recognition and tenure.
Agency Match score: 30/100 · Medium confidence: 3+ public facts
Why: Insurance or business association membership; public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry; three or more named leaders
- Insurance or business association membership · Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Inc. (OIA)shelbyagency.com
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry · For over 100 yearsshelbyagency.com
- Three or more named leaders · Justin & Tammy Armintrout, Agency Ownersshelbyagency.com
What this rating was based on (3 factors)
Based on public information. Points come from a fixed rubric. The score is a sum of points, not a probability. Confidence is shown separately and does not change the rating.
- Insurance or business association membership+15 pts
- Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Inc. (OIA)shelbyagency.com
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry (supporting)+10 pts
- For over 100 yearsshelbyagency.com
- Three or more named leaders (supporting)+5 pts
- Justin & Tammy Armintrout, Agency Ownersshelbyagency.com
- Tammy Armintrout Presidentshelbyagency.com
- Justin Armintrout Vice Presidentshelbyagency.com
Total: 30 points → Agency Match score 30/100, rated Low (High at 60+, Medium at 35+).
Confidence (separate from the rating): Medium confidence: 3+ public facts · 5 facts from 1 website.
Not known publicly: Whether the principals want to mentor or be mentored.
Business Partnerships
Low · 30Public signs the agency would complement others: niche specialties, referral or partner relationships, broad carrier access, both personal and commercial lines, and regional reach.
Agency Match score: 30/100 · Medium confidence: 3+ public facts
Why: Three or more carriers named; several documented lines of business; two or more documented offices
- Three or more carriers named · Specializing in Erie Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Several documented lines of business · Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Two or more documented offices · 55 West Main Street Shelby, Ohio 44875shelbyagency.com
What this rating was based on (3 factors)
Based on public information. Points come from a fixed rubric. The score is a sum of points, not a probability. Confidence is shown separately and does not change the rating.
- Three or more carriers named+15 pts
- Specializing in Erie Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- CNAshelbyagency.com
- Celinashelbyagency.com
- Foremostshelbyagency.com
- Hagertyshelbyagency.com
- Progressiveshelbyagency.com
- Prudentialshelbyagency.com
- Hartfordshelbyagency.com
- Several documented lines of business (supporting)+10 pts
- Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Auto, Home, Personal, Business, Life Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Auto, Home, and Personal Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Business Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Life Insuranceshelbyagency.com
- Two or more documented offices (supporting)+5 pts
- 55 West Main Street Shelby, Ohio 44875shelbyagency.com
- 1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield, Ohio 44906shelbyagency.com
Total: 30 points → Agency Match score 30/100, rated Low (High at 60+, Medium at 35+).
Confidence (separate from the rating): Medium confidence: 3+ public facts · 15 facts from 1 website.
Not known publicly: Which partnerships the agency would welcome; Carrier appointments not published online.
Record & channel
Ohio resident business-entity license (NPN 1882164), licensed at Shelby, OH
gateway.insurance.ohio.govIndependent agency
“As an independent insurance agency, we partner with some of the top insurance companies in the industry”shelbyagency.com
Not confirmed. Names on a website or license are not treated as proof of who owns the agency.
Website: www.shelbyagency.com
Locations & footprint
Shelby, Ohio
Operating office
Mansfield, Ohio
Operating office
Documented offices are not necessarily the full service area. Acquisitions do not establish additional offices.
Highlights
Story so far
- 2019
Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency
Published - 2019
Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency
Published - —
Family-owned business
Published
People & affiliations
Justin & Tammy Armintrout Agency Owners
Tammy Armintrout President Direct
Justin Armintrout Vice President Direct
Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Inc. (OIA)
National Association of Professional Insurance Agents (PIA)
National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB)
Richland Area Chamber & Economic Development
Names & entities
Legal name on license record
Facts from published sources (34 verified)
55 West Main Street Shelby, Ohio 44875
“Shelby Office Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. 55 West Main Street Shelby , Ohio 44875”shelbyagency.com
1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield, Ohio 44906
“Mansfield Office C&S Insurance Agency 1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield , Ohio 44906”shelbyagency.com
Independent insurance agency
“As an independent insurance agency, we partner with some of the top insurance companies in the industry”shelbyagency.com
Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency
“In 2019 our agency family grew with the acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency adding a 2nd location in Mansfield, Ohio”shelbyagency.com
Justin & Tammy Armintrout, Agency Owners
“Justin & Tammy Armintrout Agency Owners”shelbyagency.com
Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance
“Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. and C&S Insurance Agency specializes in auto, home, life, and business insurance.”shelbyagency.com
Specializing in Erie Insurance
“Specializing In Erie Insurance Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.”shelbyagency.com
Shelby, Mansfield, and All of Ohio
“Insuring Shelby, Mansfield, and All of Ohio For over 100 years The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. has been providing insurance services in Shelby and throughout Ohio.”shelbyagency.com
55 West Main Street Shelby , Ohio 44875
“Shelby Office Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. 55 West Main Street Shelby , Ohio 44875”shelbyagency.com
1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield , Ohio 44906
“Mansfield Office C&S Insurance Agency 1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield , Ohio 44906”shelbyagency.com
For over 100 years
“For over 100 years The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. has been providing insurance services in Shelby and throughout Ohio.”shelbyagency.com
Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency
“In 2019 our agency family grew with the acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency adding a 2nd location in Mansfield, Ohio”shelbyagency.com
Independent insurance agency
“As an independent insurance agency, we partner with some of the top insurance companies in the industry”shelbyagency.com
Family-owned business
“As a family-owned business, we pride ourselves on treating our customers like they are family.”shelbyagency.com
Auto, Home, Personal, Business, Life Insurance
“Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. provides auto, home, life, and business insurance to all of Ohio”shelbyagency.com
Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Inc. (OIA)
“Professional Associations Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Inc. (OIA)”shelbyagency.com
Association role: National Association of Professional Insurance Agents (PIA)
“National Association of Professional Insurance Agents (PIA)”shelbyagency.com
Association role: National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB)
“National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB)”shelbyagency.com
Richland Area Chamber & Economic Development
“Community Associations Richland Area Chamber & Economic Development”shelbyagency.com
55 West Main Street Shelby , Ohio 44875
“Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. 55 West Main Street Shelby , Ohio 44875”shelbyagency.com
1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield , Ohio 44906
“Mansfield Office C&S Insurance Agency 1500 West 4th Street Unit 5 Mansfield , Ohio 44906”shelbyagency.com
Tammy Armintrout President
“Tammy Armintrout President Direct”shelbyagency.com
Justin Armintrout Vice President
“Justin Armintrout Vice President Direct”shelbyagency.com
Auto, Home, and Personal Insurance
“Insurance Auto, Home, and Personal Insurance Business Insurance Life Insurance”shelbyagency.com
Business Insurance
“Insurance Auto, Home, and Personal Insurance Business Insurance Life Insurance”shelbyagency.com
Life Insurance
“Insurance Auto, Home, and Personal Insurance Business Insurance Life Insurance”shelbyagency.com
all of Ohio, including Mansfield, Shelby, and Willard
“Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency Inc. provides auto, home, life, and business insurance to all of Ohio, including Mansfield, Shelby, and Willard.”shelbyagency.com