Looking to Buy
Find agencies with characteristics associated with buying other agencies or books of business.
Agency Match uses public information and a proprietary scoring model to identify possible business opportunities. Ratings indicate potential, not confirmed interest, unless explicitly noted.
High 10 · Medium 19 · Low 133 · Insufficient Evidence 657 · Not assessed (exclusive carrier) 164 · Held: research incomplete 2
29 agencies rated High or Medium
Ferrell and Hill Insurance Agency LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Madison & Charleston · West Virginia
Documented acquisition of another agency
CB Hall Insurance Agency acquired
Auto, Motorcycle, Business, Bonds, Church, Commercial, Home, Life, Health, RV, ATV, Boat
Looking to Buy: High · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Dustin Burgess Insurance Group LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Alliance & Akron & Wadsworth · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
A-Z Insurance Agency
Home, Auto, Life, Long-Term Care, Umbrella, Farm, HOA, Non-Profit, Business, Employee Benefits
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: High
Insurance Systems Group INC
Independent agency
Offices: Cleveland & Warren · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Beardsley Agency
Insurance, Risk Management and Financial Services
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Littman-thomas Agency INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Greenville & Bradford & Troy · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Sargent & Associates Agency (2005)
Renters insurance
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Meyer-badenhop Ins Agcy INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Leipsic · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Badenhop Agency in Hamler, Ohio
Auto, Homeowner's, Umbrella, Farm, Health, Life, Business, Event, Bonds
Looking to Buy: High
Whitaker-myers Ins Agcy INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Wooster & Ashland · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Badger Insurance Agency (1984)
Insurance, Wealth Management, Benefits, Tax
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Bickle Ins Services LLC
Independent agency
Athens · Ohio · Licensed in state
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired agencies with policies from 1909
Personal, Business, Employee Benefits, Financial Planning
Looking to Buy: High
Dwyer Family Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Cincinnati · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Herb Bell Insurance Agency
Home, Auto, Life, Business, Pet, Umbrella Insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: High · Looking to Buy: High
Mutual Insurance Partners (Pro Insurance Group / JL Massie)
Independent agency
Offices: Follansbee · West Virginia
Documented acquisition of another agency
Later in 2023, Marracino Insurance Agency of Wintersville, OH and Williams Insurance Agency of Bergholz, OH were acquired
Personal Insurance, Commercial Insurance, Home Warranty, Farm & Agriculture, Life, Pet, Workers Compensation
Business Partnerships: High · Looking to Buy: High
The Merhar Agency LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Willoughby · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Noda Agency merged with Merhar Agency in 2018
Auto, Home, Commercial, Life, Flood, Boat/Watercraft, Condo, Motorcycle, Recreational, Renters, RV, Umbrella
Looking to Buy: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Holloway Ins INC
Independent agency
Offices: Columbiana & Lisbon · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired first agency in 1977
Personal home, auto, umbrella, business, life, health, farm/agri insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Hosket Ulen Insurance Solutions LLC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Columbus & Dayton & Upper Arlington & Dublin & Miamisburg · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Masters & Associates Insurance
Personal, Business, Employee Benefits
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Deangelis Insurance INC
Independent agency
Offices: Stow · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired The Insurance Shop in 2009
Personal Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Recreational Vehicle Insurance, Umbrella Insurance, Business Owners Insurance, Property Insurance, Liability Insurance, Business Auto Insurance, Bonds, Life Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium
Derrow Insurance INC
Independent agency
Offices: Wellston · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Purchased Waugh Insurance
Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Devaul-buntain Insurance Agency INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Kent & Richfield · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
We have exciting news in that we have acquired another location in Richfield, Ohio – it is the Broadview Insurance Agency and is located at 4025 Broadview Rd.,
Auto, Home, Business, Life, Long-Term Care, Surety Bonds, Medicare
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Insurance Centers Inc
Independent agency
Morgantown · West Virginia · Licensed in state
Documented acquisition of another agency
Insurance Centers acquires Mountain State Insurance Center in Terra Alta, WV, adding a third Preston County location.
Looking to Buy: Medium
M J Knapp Insurance Agency Incorporated
Independent agency
Offices: Richwood · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Purchased Roger Shearer’s Insurance Agency
Commercial, Personal, Life, Farm, Recreational, Classic Vehicle
Looking to Buy: Medium · Business Partnerships: Medium
Martin - Lark Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Rossford · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Insurance Solutions acquired
Personal, Business, Health, Life, Medicare Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Looking to Buy: Medium
Mountain State Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Charleston · West Virginia
Documented acquisition of another agency
In January of 2019 Mountain State Insurance purchased the Ted V.
Insurance, employee benefits, and financial services
Mentorship & Peer Connections: High · Looking to Buy: Medium
Quad State Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Martinsburg & Kingwood · West Virginia
States it grew by acquiring agencies
In January 2023, Quad State grew stronger by acquiring the respected Hartley Insurance Agency in Kingwood, WV .
Personal and Commercial Lines Insurance
Business Partnerships: High · Looking to Buy: Medium
Tuscarawas Agency Company
Independent agency
Offices: New Philadelphia & Strasburg & Barnesville & Sugarcreek · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Kemp Insurance of Barnesville provided services to clients for nearly 50 years before merging with Tuscarawas Insurance Agency in February.
Looking to Buy: Medium
The Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Shelby & Mansfield · Ohio
States it grew by acquiring agencies
Acquisition of C&S Insurance Agency
Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance
Looking to Buy: Medium
Campbell Insurance Group LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Carroll · Ohio
Documented acquisition of another agency
Acquired Garner Insurance Agents
Auto, Home, Commercial, Life, Boat, RV, etc.
Business Partnerships: Medium · Looking to Buy: Medium
Capital Insurance Group
Independent agency
Offices: Charleston & Columbus & Huntington & Cincinnati & Morgantown · West Virginia
Documented expansion (new office or book)
has grown its service area to include most of the east coa
Personal & Business Insurance
Business Partnerships: High · Looking to Buy: Medium