Mentorship & Peer Connections in West Virginia
Discover experienced agencies and insurance professionals worth connecting with.
Agency Match uses public information and a proprietary scoring model to identify possible business opportunities. Ratings indicate potential, not confirmed interest, unless explicitly noted.
High 3 · Medium 16 · Low 43 · Insufficient Evidence 283
19 agencies rated High or Medium
Waters Fanta Insurance Agency LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Parkersburg & Ripley · West Virginia
Named leadership role in an insurance association
Big I
Personal Insurance, Business Insurance, Auto, Flood, Homeowners, Renters, RV, Umbrella, Commercial, Workers' Comp, Bonding
Mentorship & Peer Connections: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Ashley Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Spencer · West Virginia
Named leadership role in an insurance association
Suzette Raines-Ashley, Past President Ashley Insurance Agency, Spencer
Auto, Home, Life, Commercial, Farm, Flood, Umbrella, Workers Comp, Bonds
Mentorship & Peer Connections: High · Business Partnerships: Medium
Mountain State Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Charleston · West Virginia
Named leadership role in an insurance association
Brady Campbell, Treasurer Mountain State Insurance Agency, Inc., Charleston
Insurance, employee benefits, and financial services
Mentorship & Peer Connections: High · Looking to Buy: Medium
Hazlett, Burt & Watson, INC.
Independent agency
Offices: Wheeling & Vienna & Barnesville · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of FINRA, SIPC, SIFMA
Financial Planning, Investment Planning, Retirement Planning, Banking and Lending, Insurance Planning, Brokerage Services
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Ferrell and Hill Insurance Agency LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Madison & Charleston · West Virginia
Named leadership role in an insurance association
Chris Parker, Board President Ferrell & Hill Insurance Agency, LLC, Madison
Auto, Motorcycle, Business, Bonds, Church, Commercial, Home, Life, Health, RV, ATV, Boat
Looking to Buy: High · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Advocate Insurance Group
Independent agency
Offices: Martinsburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
In addition to being mom, Michelle is very involved in the community and serves on several boards including her local Rotary Club, Berkeley County Chamber of Co
Auto, Home, Business, Life Insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Parrack Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Elkins & Point Pleasant & Buckhannon · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Mason County Chamber of Commerce Member
Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Farm Insurance, Business Insurance, Life Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Raymond L. Thompson
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Kingwood · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of The Rotary Club of Kingwood
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Business, Life, Health, Pet, Banking, Annuities
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Arndt-McBee Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Martinsburg & Berkeley Springs · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Rotary, Chamber of Commerce
Auto, home, life, health, and commercial insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Bill Straub Jr. Insurance Agency
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Beckley · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
National Association of Insurance & Financial Advisors
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Fitzer Insurance Services, LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Parkersburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of SIAA
Business Insurance, Employee Benefits, Personal Insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Intra-State Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Parkersburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of SIAA
Business Insurance, Employee Benefits, Personal Insurance
Business Partnerships: High · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Jodie Parrack Insurance Agency INC.
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Elkins · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of the GFWC Woman's Club of Elkins
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Lisa Shepherd Ins Agency INC
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: New Martinsville · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
State Farm Insurance Agent – Lisa Shepherd
auto, home, renters, life, ATVs, motorcycle, boat, camper insurance
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Loudin Ins Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Buckhannon · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Trusted Choice, Buckhannon Upshur Chamber of Commerce, West Virginia Farm Bureau, Southern Upshur Business Association, Rotary Club of Buckhannon – Upshur
Home, Auto, Life, Business, Employee Benefits
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Mike Mccoy Insurance Agency, INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Moundsville · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member Marshall County Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Home, Life, Renters, Business, Motorcycle, Condo, Rec Vehicles, Boat, Banking
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Mutual Insurance Partners (Pro Insurance Group / JL Massie)
Independent agency
Offices: Follansbee · West Virginia
Teaching or speaking role
Mutual Insurance Partners has a proven track record of helping guide insurance agency owners through the process of selling, merging or achieving desired scale.
Personal Insurance, Commercial Insurance, Home Warranty, Farm & Agriculture, Life, Pet, Workers Compensation
Business Partnerships: High · Looking to Buy: High
Stephanie Hayhurst-hall Agency
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Bridgeport · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Harrison County Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, Banking, Annuities
Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Tri-point Insurance, INC
Independent agency
Offices: Point Pleasant · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Mason County Chamber of Commerce
Business Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium · Mentorship & Peer Connections: Medium
Research leads rated Low (43)
Each lead keeps the evidence already on its profile. A Low rating is not a sign the owner wants to sell.
Blue Ridge Risk Partners
Independent agency
Bridgeport · West Virginia · Licensed in state
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
Top 75 insurance agency in the US
Home, Auto, RV, Umbrella, Renter's, Flood
Business Partnerships: High
Bray & Oakley Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Logan · West Virginia · Licensed in state
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
Erie Life Recognition Award 2018 Safeco Elite Agent
Carl Stephen Westfall
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Ripley · West Virginia
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
Jackson County Insurance Agent for the year 2025
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, Banking, Annuities
Gesner Insurance Agency, INC.
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Huntington · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Community Associations, Big Brothers Big Sisters of the Tri-State Chamber of Commerce
auto, home, life, and business insurance, and surety bonds
Business Partnerships: Medium
Gj Garton Insurance Agency INC
Independent agency
Offices: Weston & Parsons & Grantsville · West Virginia
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
2017 Giving Network Agency of the Year Award
home insurance, auto insurance, business insurance, employee benefits
Business Partnerships: High
Hildebrand Insurance Group INC
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Parkersburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of National Association of Insurance Marketers (NAIM) since 1998
Disability, Life, Group and Individual Health, Medicare Supplements, Dental, Fixed Annuities, Critical Illness
Lorin Walls Ins. Agcy., INC.
Independent agency
Offices: Crab Orchard · West Virginia
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
Quality Agent Award from Erie Insurance
Auto, Home, Business, Life, Health, Employee Benefits
Business Partnerships: Medium
Maiden Insurance LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Ranson · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Jefferson County Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Home, Life, and Business Insurance
Ray Crabtree Insurance Agency INC
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Huntington · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Banking
Rhodes Insurance Services (Gary Rhodes Agency)
Independent agency
Offices: Parkersburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Gary is very active in the Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Homeowners, Renters, Life, Business, Farm, RV, Motorcycle, ATV, Boat
Business Partnerships: Medium
Tammy Sirbaugh Agency
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Ranson · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of the Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, Banking, Investment Services, Annuities
Appalachian Insurance Agency
Independent agency
Offices: Beckley · West Virginia
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
earned them ERIE's most prestigious award, The F.W. Hirt Quality Agency Award and got them voted as "Beckley's Best Insurance Agency."
Auto, Business, Flood, Homeowners/Mobile Home, Life, Boat
Business Partnerships: Medium
Brittany Pinkney Agency
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Weston · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Lewis County Chamber of Commerce, Weston Rotary Club, Friends of Basketball Organization
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Business, Life, Health, Pet, Banking, Annuities
Chad Broadwater Agency INC
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Wheeling · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
State Farm Insurance - Chad Broadwater | Insurance
Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet
Greenbrier Valley Insurance Agency LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Lewisburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of Greenbrier County Chamber of Commerce
Auto, Home, Business, Commercial, Life Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Jpk INC
Independent agency
Offices: Parkersburg & Vienna & Marietta & Belpre · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member Chamber Of Commerce Of The Mid-Ohio Valley
Personal and Business Insurance
Business Partnerships: High
Judy Ball Agency
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Moorefield · West Virginia
Civic or community leadership role
Board Member of the Hardy County Chamber
Kay Lewis Insurance And Financial Services INC
Exclusive / Captive Agent — State Farm
Offices: Martinsburg · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Chamber of Commerce
Insurance and Financial Services
L&l Auvil Ins Agency LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Nutter Fort · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
CIC, AU, CISR, Nutter Fort Lions Club, Harrison County Chamber of Commerce, Richie County Chamber of Commerce
auto, home, life, and business insurance
Paree Insurance Centers
Independent agency
Offices: Moundsville & Wheeling & St. Clairsville · West Virginia
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
Erie Insurance Quality Agency Award Winner
Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Business Insurance, Individual Life Insurance, Individual Health Insurance
Business Partnerships: High
Roop Ins & Financial Services INC
Independent agency
Offices: Crab Orchard · West Virginia
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
2001
Personal and Business Insurance
Talerico Insurance Agency LLC
Independent agency
Offices: Morgantown · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Independent Insurance Agents of West Virginia (IIAWV)
Auto, Home, Business, Life, Health Insurance
Business Partnerships: Medium
Wickline Insurance, INC.
Licensed agency · channel not confirmed
Offices: Beckley · West Virginia
Insurance or business association membership
Member of the Association of Financial Insurance Brokers
insurance and related services
Business Partnerships: Medium
Baker Insurance Services
Independent agency
Moorefield · West Virginia · Licensed in state
Insurance industry or carrier recognition
the Erie Insurance Founders’ Award and the Bronze Level Life Recognition Award