Schultheis Insurance LLC
Based on public information · Profile not yet claimedIndependent agency
Offices: Marietta · OhioSchultheis Insurance LLC is an independent insurance agency licensed in Marietta, OH. Lines listed: Home, Farm, Auto, Life, Disability, Long term care, Business/Commercial. Founding or history: 1928. Agency Match assessments based on public information: Business Partnerships medium; Mentorship & Peer Connections low. 28 publicly sourced facts with links.
How we determined the info on this profile
- License record: taken from the state license roster.
- Offices: based on offices listed on the agency's website. More than one office can count toward the Looking to Buy score.
- Lines of business: based on text on the agency's website. They can count toward the Strategic Partnership score.
- Leadership: based on text on the agency's website. It can count toward the Mentorship & Peer Connection score.
- Carrier partnerships: based on carrier logos on the agency's website.
- Looking to Buy: not enough public facts for a score.
- Open to Selling: not enough public facts for a score.
- Mentorship & Peer Connections: scored from public signs of leadership, teaching and association ties.
- Business Partnerships: scored from carrier logos on the agency's website and from other public facts.
Research
Detailed profile
Geography
1 documented offices
Ownership events
3
Ownership
Not confirmed
Agency Match assessments
Agency Match uses public information and a proprietary scoring model to identify possible business opportunities. Ratings indicate potential, not confirmed interest, unless explicitly noted.
Looking to Buy
Insufficient EvidencePublic signs the agency buys or absorbs other agencies: past acquisitions, growth by acquisition, added offices and the depth to integrate a book.
Why: Serves more than one state or a wide region; three or more named leaders; public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry
- Serves more than one state or a wide region · Ohio and West Virginiaschultheisinsurance.net
- Three or more named leaders · C. William O'Neill assumed control in 1959schultheisinsurance.net
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry · 1928schultheisinsurance.net
What this rating was based on (3 factors)
Based on public information. Points come from a fixed rubric. The score is a sum of points, not a probability. Confidence is shown separately and does not change the rating.
- Serves more than one state or a wide region (supporting)+10 pts
- Ohio and West Virginiaschultheisinsurance.net
- Three or more named leaders (supporting)+10 pts
- C. William O'Neill assumed control in 1959schultheisinsurance.net
- Kirk Schultheis joined in 1986schultheisinsurance.net
- Kirk Schultheisschultheisinsurance.net
- Allie Schultheisschultheisinsurance.net
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry (supporting)+5 pts
Total: 25 points → Insufficient Evidence: a rating needs at least two facts including one core factor for this assessment.
Confidence (separate from the rating): not given without a rating · 6 facts from 1 website.
Not known publicly: Whether the agency is buying now and at what size; Financing and integration capacity.
Open to Selling
Acquisition Research Fit
Low · 8Acquisition Research Fit is low. Formation year 1928 is on a verified record (98 years in operation). The rating stays Low because years in operation and size are a business profile, not a transition. This is not a statement that the agency wants to sell.
- Formation year 1928 is on a verified record (98 years in operation). Verified · +8 ptsschultheisinsurance.net
Confidence: low. Separate from the rating.
Not on file: Owner tenure is not established; No internal succession document; Confirmed sale interest is unknown.
Confirmed sale interest: Unknown
Mentorship & Peer Connections
Low · 30Public signs of industry standing and willingness to share know-how: association leadership, teaching, memberships, recognition and tenure.
Agency Match score: 30/100 · Medium confidence: 3+ public facts
Why: Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry; civic or community leadership role; public history of 30+ years in business or in the industry
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry · 1928schultheisinsurance.net
- Civic or community leadership role · Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Companyschultheisinsurance.net
- Public history of 30+ years in business or in the industry · 1928schultheisinsurance.net
- Three or more named leaders · C. William O'Neill assumed control in 1959schultheisinsurance.net
What this rating was based on (4 factors)
Based on public information. Points come from a fixed rubric. The score is a sum of points, not a probability. Confidence is shown separately and does not change the rating.
- Public history of 15+ years in business or in the industry (supporting)+10 pts
- Civic or community leadership role+10 pts
- Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Companyschultheisinsurance.net
- Public history of 30+ years in business or in the industry (supporting)+5 pts
- Three or more named leaders (supporting)+5 pts
- C. William O'Neill assumed control in 1959schultheisinsurance.net
- Kirk Schultheis joined in 1986schultheisinsurance.net
- Kirk Schultheisschultheisinsurance.net
- Allie Schultheisschultheisinsurance.net
Total: 30 points → Agency Match score 30/100, rated Low (High at 60+, Medium at 35+).
Confidence (separate from the rating): Medium confidence: 3+ public facts · 7 facts from 1 website.
Not known publicly: Whether the principals want to mentor or be mentored.
Business Partnerships
Medium · 55Public signs the agency would complement others: niche specialties, referral or partner relationships, broad carrier access, both personal and commercial lines, and regional reach.
Agency Match score: 55/100 · Medium confidence: 3+ public facts
Why: Niche specialty line documented; three or more carriers named; serves more than one state or a wide region
- Niche specialty line documented · Home, Farm, Auto, Life, Disability, Long term care, Business/Commercialschultheisinsurance.net
- Three or more carriers named · Westfieldschultheisinsurance.net
- Serves more than one state or a wide region · Ohio and West Virginiaschultheisinsurance.net
- Several documented lines of business · Home, Auto, Business, Life Insurance and Annuitiesschultheisinsurance.net
What this rating was based on (4 factors)
Based on public information. Points come from a fixed rubric. The score is a sum of points, not a probability. Confidence is shown separately and does not change the rating.
- Niche specialty line documented+20 pts
- Home, Farm, Auto, Life, Disability, Long term care, Business/Commercialschultheisinsurance.net
- Three or more carriers named+15 pts
- Westfieldschultheisinsurance.net
- Auto-Ownersschultheisinsurance.net
- Progressiveschultheisinsurance.net
- Selectiveschultheisinsurance.net
- CNAschultheisinsurance.net
- Serves more than one state or a wide region+10 pts
- Ohio and West Virginiaschultheisinsurance.net
- Several documented lines of business (supporting)+10 pts
- Home, Auto, Business, Life Insurance and Annuitiesschultheisinsurance.net
- Home and auto insuranceschultheisinsurance.net
Total: 55 points → Agency Match score 55/100, rated Medium (High at 60+, Medium at 35+).
Confidence (separate from the rating): Medium confidence: 3+ public facts · 9 facts from 1 website.
Not known publicly: Which partnerships the agency would welcome; Carrier appointments not published online.
Record & channel
Ohio resident business-entity license (NPN 21136380), licensed at Marietta, OH
gateway.insurance.ohio.govIndependent agency
“Schultheis Insurance LLC Independent Agents serving our community members in Ohio and West Virginia since 1928.”schultheisinsurance.net
Not confirmed. Names on a website or license are not treated as proof of who owns the agency.
Website: schultheisinsurance.net
Locations & footprint
Marietta, Ohio
Operating office
Documented offices are not necessarily the full service area. Acquisitions do not establish additional offices.
Highlights
Story so far
- 1951
1951
PublishedHistorical event: not credited to this agency as a buyer. Predecessor ownership change.
- 1963
1963
PublishedHistorical event: not credited to this agency as a buyer. Origin of the current agency name.
- —
Family owned and operated
Published
People & affiliations
C. William O’Neill assumed control over the O’Neill Insurance Agency in 1959 until he became the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court
Darrel’s youngest son, Kirk, joined the family business in 1986
Kirk Schultheis Kirk was born in Newport, Ohio and raised in Marietta, graduating from Marietta High School.
Allie Schultheis Allie is the youngest of Kirk’s children and is a 2011 graduate of Parkersburg Catholic High School.
Board for The O’Neill Senior Center
Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Company
Marietta Area Chamber of Commerce
Names & entities
Legal name on license record
Facts from published sources (28 verified, 1 unverified)
Marietta, OH
“Schultheis Insurance • Marietta, OH”schultheisinsurance.net
Independent Agents
“Schultheis Insurance LLC Independent Agents serving our community members in Ohio and West Virginia since 1928.”schultheisinsurance.net
1928
“Schultheis Insurance LLC Independent Agents serving our community members in Ohio and West Virginia since 1928.”schultheisinsurance.net
Home, Farm, Auto, Life, Disability, Long term care, Business/Commercial
“What We Offer Home/Farm Have a mortgage? The bank requires coverage! These policies cover all types of homes including condominiums, mobile homes, renter’s coverage, homes under construction and much more. From hobby to full time farming - we cover it all! Auto Auto policies protect the insured against comprehensive and collision accidents and include physical damage as well as property damage and bodily injury. Each state requires every driver to have a minimum amount of coverage. Life We offer term, whole or universal life insurance policies to prepare individuals and their families for expenses incurred after end of life and in the case of untimely death. We also offer annuities for retirement programs. Disability income also falls under life insurance to protect an individual from loss of income due to injury or illness. Long term care coverage is available to provide payments both in and out of a nursing home facility. Business/Commercial Our team can put together a plan to protect your small business or a larger and more specialized commercial risks.”schultheisinsurance.net
Ohio and West Virginia
“Schultheis Insurance LLC Independent Agents serving our community members in Ohio and West Virginia since 1928.”schultheisinsurance.net
1928
“In 1928, Alvin J. Jolly founded the Jolly Insurance Agency in Marietta, Ohio after graduating from Marietta College.”schultheisinsurance.net
Marietta, Ohio
“In 1928, Alvin J. Jolly founded the Jolly Insurance Agency in Marietta, Ohio after graduating from Marietta College.”schultheisinsurance.net
1951
“It was upon Mr. Jolly’s death in 1951 that Daniel A.T. O’Neill and family purchased the business and renamed it O’Neill Insurance Agency.”schultheisinsurance.net
C. William O'Neill assumed control in 1959
“C. William O’Neill assumed control over the O’Neill Insurance Agency in 1959 until he became the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court”schultheisinsurance.net
1963
“It was at this time in September of 1963, that Bill approached his friend Darrel, who agreed to purchase the insurance agency that then became Schultheis Insurance.”schultheisinsurance.net
Kirk Schultheis joined in 1986
“Darrel’s youngest son, Kirk, joined the family business in 1986”schultheisinsurance.net
418 Third Street
“in 1989, after being located at One Courthouse Lane for 15 years, Schultheis Insurance relocated for the final time to our current location at 418 Third Street.”schultheisinsurance.net
Family owned and operated
“We are a second generation, family owned and operated agency with a third generation of Schultheis working and learning alongside her father.”schultheisinsurance.net
Mid-Ohio Valley
“Schultheis Insurance has been committed to serving the Mid-Ohio Valley community for almost 100 years and will continue to do so with loyalty and honesty.”schultheisinsurance.net
Marietta, OH
“Kirk was born in Newport, Ohio and raised in Marietta, graduating from Marietta High School.”schultheisinsurance.net
1986
“In October of 1986, Kirk joined his father, Darrel, in the family business where together, they continued to grow the agency into a Mid-Ohio Valley small business staple.”schultheisinsurance.net
Kirk Schultheis
“Kirk Schultheis Kirk was born in Newport, Ohio and raised in Marietta, graduating from Marietta High School.”schultheisinsurance.net
Allie Schultheis
“Allie Schultheis Allie is the youngest of Kirk’s children and is a 2011 graduate of Parkersburg Catholic High School.”schultheisinsurance.net
Home, Auto, Business, Life Insurance and Annuities
“Allie is mom to June the Black Lab, Humane Society of the Ohio Valley Alumni, and Bruce the Bernese Mountain Dog, a rescue from Freedom Tails of Ohio - both of whom make visits to work. She married Skylar Fouss of Marietta in June of 2023 and became a mom in 2026 and is now raising a fourth generation female community business leader. Allie currently serves on the Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Company and the Marietta Area Chamber of Commerce. Jenny Eastes Jenny is a Marietta native and graduate of Marietta High School. She started working in insurance for another local agency in 1985 as a Property and Casualty Insurance Producer. Jenny is also certified in Life Insurance. She joined the Schultheis Insurance family in January of 1999. In addition to being a licensed agent, Jenny is also a certified notary. In her free time, Jenny is an avid and incredible cook and enjoys spending time with her husband of 25 years, Randy, and their four sweet grandbabies and her loving dogs, Alex & Getty. You can often times find Jenny front row at Peoples Bank Theater! Jenny is retiring in May of 2026. Lindsay Mulvey Lindsay has been employed at Schultheis Insurance since August of 2021. Originally a Pittsburgh, Pa native, Lindsay attended college at Slippery Rock University before marrying her high school sweetheart, Michael in 2018. They have lived in several cities throughout Pennsylvania and Ohio before landing in Marietta for Michael’s career as a collegiate baseball coach where Lindsay always specialized in the health and nutrition industry. Linday obtained her Property & Casualty license in 2024 and focuses on home and auto insurance and most often works remotely keeping us all in check. When not working at Schultheis, Lindsay is the owner and operater of her own small business, Another Bark in the Wall, which is an in home dog daycare and training service. Her dog, Harley, is a frequent flyer in the office. Jess Banyas Jess joined the Schultheis Insurance family in 2025. She is a native of Wheeling, WV where she previously worked at the Oglebay Institute after obtaining her degree in Social Work from the Franciscan University of Stuebenville. Jess handles the day to day office tasks and all things customer relations focused. Jess and her high school sweetheart, Robby, relocated with their daughter to Marietta in 2025. Honorary Team Members Chaz 2001–2015 Major 2013-2021 Leesie 2015-2022 Willie 2020 June 2015 Murphy 2015-2022 Bruce 2022 George 2022 © Schultheis Insurance, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Website by: 740 Marketing | Webmaster | Privacy Policy”schultheisinsurance.net
Home and auto insurance
“Linday obtained her Property & Casualty license in 2024 and focuses on home and auto insurance and most often works remotely keeping us all in check.”schultheisinsurance.net
Board for The O’Neill Senior Center
“Kirk currently serves on the Board for The O’Neill Senior Center and the Harvest of Hope.”schultheisinsurance.net
Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Company
“Allie currently serves on the Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Company and the Marietta Area Chamber of Commerce.”schultheisinsurance.net
Marietta Area Chamber of Commerce
“Allie currently serves on the Board for the Historic Harmar Bridge Company and the Marietta Area Chamber of Commerce.”schultheisinsurance.net
Show 1 unverified fact (did not pass QA)
The First National Bank Building
“At the time, the office was located in The First National Bank Building where it remained until the year 1974.”
QA note: Unverified: year not in quote. Shown for transparency; not treated as a fact.
schultheisinsurance.net